Buyers Guide to the Best RV Toilet 2018

Are you in the market for a new RV toilet? From low profile to high profile toilets, check out our Buyer’s Guide to the best RV toilet. With so many different types of RV toilets to choose from, here’s what you need to know to choose the type that’s best for you.

   
Thetford Aqua Magic V Pedal Flush RV Toilet
Thetford Aqua Magic Style II RV Toilet
Thetford Aqua-Magic Bravura RV Toilet
Dometic 310 Series RV Toilet
Dometic 320 Series RV Toilet

What Are the Different Types of RV Toilets?

Low Profile vs. High Profile Toilets

A low profile RV toilet is shorter from top to base. It’s useful in tight spaces and can be placed on raised platforms for convenience. High profile toilets are closer in height (or taller than) regular household toilets. To make sure you choose the right height for you, measure the height of a toilet that you find comfortable. Even an inch or two can make a big difference. Generally, taller toilets are easier to use for people with mobility issues.

Gravity Flush

A gravity flush toilet is positioned over the waste holding tank. When flushed, the waste drops directly into the tank. The gravity flush toilet is the traditional RV toilet. It’s simple and reliable with fewer moving parts.

Macerating Flush

The macerating flush toilet chops the waste into sludge. It is then pumped to the waste holding tank. Electricity is required to run the motor for the chopping blades. One advantage of this type of toilet is that it can be installed in different places. It doesn’t need to be directly above the waste holding tank.

Vacuum Flush

Like the macerating flush toilet, the vacuum flush toilet uses a stored vacuum vessel and macerating vacuum pump to turn the waste to sludge and pump to the holding tank. Like the macerating flush toilet, it can be installed in different places. It doesn’t need to be directly above the waste holding tank

Cassette

The cassette RV toilet is a cross between a traditional gravity flush toilet and a portable toilet. It’s a permanent toilet with a removable “cassette” or waste tank. Contents flush directly into a removable waste tank. To empty the cassette, simply remove it through a service door. Once emptied, reinstall under the toilet.

Portable

A portable toilet is a light-weight, movable toilet. Most portable toilets have two sections: the top toilet section and a bottom waste holding tank. To empty, simply remove the waste holding tank, empty and reattach. Portable toilets tend to cheaper, more compact and are easy to move as needed. For more information on portable toilets, check out our Buyer’s Guides to the Best Portable Toilet for Camping and the Best Portable Toilet for Home Use.

Composting Toilets

Composting toilets compost human waste. Depending on the type of toilet, they may require electricity to operate and tend to be more expensive than other toilet types.

What is RV Toilet Paper?

RV toilet paper is easy to dissolve and breaks down quickly. It prevents clogs, blockages and won’t stick to the walls of the waste holding tank. When choosing the type of toilet paper to use in your RV, check the packaging. Look for phrases such as “Safe for RV Use” and “Safe for Septic Systems”. However, just because it’s safe for septic systems doesn’t mean that it’s truly safe for your RV. To make sure your toilet paper really dissolves, try the quick test in this video:

 

Our Top Picks for the Best RV Toilet

The best RV toilet is comfortable, easy to use and easy to clean. Based on these criteria, here are our top five picks for the best RV toilet.

Thetford Aqua Magic V Pedal Flush RV Toilet

The Thetford Aqua Magic V Pedal Flush RV Toilet comes from the world’s leading manufacturer of mobile sanitation products for RV’s. It comes in two sizes: high profile or low profile and in two colors: white and parchment.

The Thetford Aqua Magic V is a classic style RV toilet that is lightweight and easy to install. An optional hand sprayer is also available. This model has a convenient single foot pedal flush. To operate, press halfway to add water and then press fully to flush.

It’s also available in a hand flush model as the Thetford 31667 Aqua-Magic V RV Toilet with Hand Flush.

Customers have said that the bowl is too shallow. Others have said that water will spray out of the toilet when you flush. To avoid this, make sure the lid is closed before flushing. Unlike the Aqua Magic IV, this model is made of a lightweight plastic.

Pros

  • 2 Sizes: high profile and low profile
  • 2 Colors: white and parchment
  • Classic styling
  • Single pedal flush – press halfway to add water, press fully to flush
  • Lightweight and easy to install

Cons

  • Bowl is shallow
  • Water may spray out of the toilet when flushing (make sure to close the lid before flushing)
  • Made of plastic, not porcelain

 


Thetford Aqua Magic Style II RV Toilet

The Thetford Aqua Magic Style II RV Toilet is a contemporary style toilet that’s taller than others at 17.5” for the high profile model. It comes in two sizes: high profile and low profile and two colors: white and bone.

The Thetford Aqua Magic Style II has a full-size residential seat that’s antimicrobial to reduce odor-causing bacteria and mold. More expensive than the Aqua Magic V, it features an easy to clean china bowl and single pedal flush.

It’s also available with a water saving hand sprayer included in this model – Thetford 42060 Aqua Magic Style II RV Toilet with Water Saver, High Profile – White

Customers said the seat is difficult to clean. It has a webbing design on the underside to strengthen the seat. Unfortunately, the webbing creates crevices that are hard to sanitize and keep clean. Others said the flush water doesn’t cover the full bowl.

Pros

  • 2 Sizes: high profile and low profile
  • China bowl
  • Full-size residential seat
  • Single pedal flush
  • Antimicrobial seat

Cons

  • Seat is difficult to clean
  • Flush water doesn’t cover the full bowl


Thetford Aqua-Magic Bravura RV Toilet

The Thetford Aqua-Magic Bravura RV Toilet is an elegant, lightweight, all plastic RV toilet. It comes in two sizes: high profile and low profile and two colors: white and parchment. It can be purchased with or without the optional hand sprayer.

The Thetford Aqua-Magic Bravura has a large, single pedal flush. To operate, press halfway to add water and then press fully to flush. It uses a strong pulsating flush for superior full bowl coverage. The seat and cover are simple to remove for cleaning or service. A pull-off front shroud provides easy access for installation.

Some customers said it has a noisy flush. Others found the toilet seat uncomfortable and wanted it to be wider and flatter.

Pros

  • Two sizes: high and low profile
  • Single pedal flush
  • Pulsating jet flush
  • Seat and cover remove for cleaning
  • Easy to install with a removable front panel

Cons

  • Noisy flush
  • Seat uncomfortable

 


Dometic 310 Series RV Toilet

The Dometic 310 Series RV Toilet is a gravity flush system toilet. It comes in two sizes: low profile or standard height and a choice of two different colors, white or bone. It is also available with an optional hand sprayer.

The Dometic 310 Series has a full-size easy to clean ceramic bowl and 360-degree vortex flush pattern. It’s easy to install with a two-bolt installation. For added comfort, it offers an ergonomic pressure-sensitive foot pedal and slow-close seat.

While the bowl is ceramic, the toilet seat is plastic. Customers have said the seat cannot be replaced with a different type seat due to the vacuum cover. Other customers said it didn’t flush fully.

Pros

  • Gravity flush system
  • Two sizes: low profile or standard height
  • Full-size easy clean ceramic bowl
  • Two-bolt installation
  • Large full-size slow-close seat
  • Ergonomic foot pedal

Cons

  • Plastic toilet seat
  • Can’t replace plastic toilet seat with a different type of seat due to the vacuum cover
  • Some customers said it didn’t flush fully


Dometic 320 Series RV Toilet

The Dometic 320 Series RV Toilet is the newer, updated version of the Dometic 310 Series. Like the previous model, the Dometic 320 Series is available in low profile or standard height. It comes in a choice of two colors: white or bone. An optional hand sprayer is also available.

The Dometic 320 Series has several updates. It has a pressurized full-rim flush for easy cleaning. With a full-sized wood seat and deep, elongated ceramic bowl, it has all the comforts of a household toilet. The hands-free foot pedal allows you to press partially to add water, and then press fully to flush.

The new wood seat is not a quiet, slow close lid. Some customers said the hinge on the lid squeaks but can be quieted by putting a dab of silicone grease on the hinge. The optional hand sprayer only comes in white. This can result in a color mismatch if you purchase the bone colored toilet.

Pros

  • Gravity Flush
  • Two sizes: low profile or standard height
  • Deep, elongated ceramic bowl
  • Full-size residential-style wood seat
  • Ergonomic foot pedal
  • Two-bolt installation

Cons

  • Lid squeaking – use a dab of silicone grease on the hinge
  • Not a self-closing lid, not a slow close lid
  • Optional hand sprayer only comes in white, not available in bone


Conclusion

When choosing an RV toilet, there are several options to consider. Depending on your space requirements, you can choose a high or low profile toilet. Will a budget model suit your needs? Or are you looking for a sturdier model to withstand long-term, continued use? Ceramic toilets are sturdier and easier to keep clean. But plastic models can be lightweight and easier to install.

For long-term, continual use, our best-rated RV toilet is the Dometic 320 Series RV Toilet. It’s built for comfort with a full-size wood seat and deep bowl. The ceramic bowl and full-rim flush make it easy to clean and maintain. The hands-free foot pedal provides an easy, sanitary flush.

These are our top picks for the best RV toilet. We based our choices on ease of use, ease of cleaning and comfort. Any of these toilets will do the trick, but the best RV toilet is whichever one works best for your own personal situation.

 

best rv toilet

 

Leave a Comment